Logo Eara

Cancer

AuthorEARA team
Cancer research is one of the most active areas of biomedical science and one where animal studies continue to play a central role. Cancer is not a single disease but a broad group of conditions involving complex interactions between genes, cells, tissues, the immune system and the wider body. While new approach methodologies, including non-animal methods, are increasingly important, many critical questions about how cancers develop, spread and respond to treatment can currently only be answered by studying living organisms. 
Cancer remains one of the leading causes of death globally, accounting for one in four deaths in the European Union. Despite this burden, significant progress in understanding and treating cancer accelerated in the last two decades. Much of this progress has relied on animal research, not only to uncover how cancers arise and evolve, but also to translate discoveries into safe and effective treatments for patients. 
Cancer is a complex group of diseases that develop through a stepwise process involving changes in genes, cell behaviour, interactions with surrounding tissues and, in many cases, evasion of the immune system. A defining feature of many cancers is metastasis, or the ability of tumour cells to spread to distant organs, which depends on coordinated interactions across multiple organs and tissues. These processes unfold over time and are influenced by the whole body, including metabolism, hormones and inflammation. Current knowledge gaps remain substantial, particularly in understanding why some tumours resist treatment, how cancers spread to distant organs and why therapies work for some patients but not others. 
Animals make it possible to study tumour growth, cancer spread, immune responses and treatment effects within the context of the whole organism, which isolated cells, 3D cell cultures with different cell types or computer models cannot capture alone. Their use has been essential both for fundamental discoveries and for the development of modern cancer therapies that have dramatically improved survival rates for many cancers.  

Research involving animals is essential for us to save lives. Most cancer treatments used today wouldn’t exist without this type of work.

Cancer Research UK

Why are animals used to study cancer? 

Media Bank Image
Animal studies are used throughout the cancer research pipeline, from basic research to clinical translation. 
Many animals naturally develop cancers that resemble those seen in people, including breast, skin and blood cancers. Studying these naturally occurring diseases helps researchers understand how tumours arise, grow and spread in a living body, and provides insight into cancer biology that is relevant to both common and rare cancers. 
Research in cancer can also involve using animals in which cancer is induced by activating cancer-causing genes, exposing animals to carcinogenic substances or transplanting tumours into the body. Genetically modified animals can be predisposed to specific cancers, allowing researchers to study disease mechanisms that closely mirror those seen in patients. 
Animals that do not naturally develop certain cancers can also be genetically engineered to model human diseases. For example, fruit flies have been used to study different types of cancer by introducing human cancer-related genes and observing how tumours develop. 
An emerging area of cancer research involves personalised approaches, where tumour cells from individual patients are transplanted into animals to create “avatars” of that patient’s cancer. These approaches can help predict how a specific tumour might respond to different treatments and inform dosing strategies, something that would not be possible to test directly in patients. 
Some cancer studies use humanised mice, which are specially modified to carry components of the human immune system. This type of mouse allows researchers to study how human tumours interact with immune cells in a living body, something that cannot be fully replicated using cell cultures or in vitro methods alone.  

Which cancer research areas benefits from animal research?

Immunotherapy has transformed cancer treatment by harnessing the body’s own immune system to target cancer cells. One major class of immunotherapy, known as checkpoint inhibitors, was first shown to be effective in mice by revealing how cancer cells suppress immune responses. Animal studies enabled researchers to understand the molecular “brakes” used by tumours to evade immune attack and to identify ways to block them. This work laid the foundation for checkpoint inhibitor therapies now used to treat cancers of the lung, kidney, skin and lymphatic system. The pioneers of this approach were awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 2018. 
Animal research continues to play a crucial role in improving immunotherapy and understanding why it works well for some patients but not others. A recent UK study, at the Wellcome Sanger Institute, identified two genes that influence how tumours respond to immunotherapy. By combining cancer cells from patients with cells from their own immune system and testing the findings in genetically modified mice, researchers showed that tumours lacking these genes were more vulnerable to immune attack. In these mice, tumours grew more slowly and were more likely to regress when treated with immunotherapy. Data from patients supported these findings, suggesting that such genes could be used as predictors of which patients are most likely to benefit from treatment. 
In pancreatic cancer, one of the most difficult cancers to treat, decades of animal research paved the way for a new clinical trial in the UK combining an immunotherapy drug, pembrolizumab, with the targeted therapy olaparib. Pembrolizumab was first studied in humanised mice, where it was shown to help the immune system recognise and attack cancer cells, while olaparib was originally tested in mice to demonstrate how it prevents cancer cells from repairing DNA damage. Together, these approaches are now being tested in patients whose tumours carry specific genetic changes, aiming to improve outcomes while reducing unnecessary side effects. 

EARA member Uppsala University has shown that a new antibody treatment in mice combining multiple immune-activating functions can both slow tumour growth and, at higher doses, prevent cancer from developing altogether. By precisely targeting cancer-specific gene alterations and amplifying the activity of specific immune cells, this approach is used to test complex, immune-based therapies before they are considered for use in people.  

Why haven’t we found a cure for cancer?
Cancer is often described as one disease, but it is actually hundreds of different diseases with distinct causes and behaviours. Even patients with the same diagnosis may have tumours that grow and respond to therapy in very different ways. This diversity means there is unlikely to be one universal cure. Instead, progress comes from developing targeted therapies and prevention strategies for specific cancers. Research has already transformed survival rates for several cancers, while work continues to overcome treatment resistance, tumour spread and individual differences.

Which animals are used in cancer research?

Zebrafish offer unique advantages in cancer research, particularly because their transparent embryos make it easier to visualise cancer cells and tumours in living animals, as well as track how they may spread. Cancer cells from patients can be transplanted into zebrafish to rapidly assess how tumours respond to different treatments and their toxicity. 

By artificially introducing genes linked to cancer into zebrafish, these animals can develop tumours that have very similar characteristics to human cancers. 

Zebrafish embryos are also widely used in genetic screens. These large-scale tests in which normal animals are compared with those that have had specific mutations introduced, to detect differences between them, allowing researchers to identify genes, molecules and pathways involved in cancer, thus supporting drug discovery. 

However, zebrafish cannot model every aspect of cancer seen in mammals. Some organs commonly affected by cancers, such as the lung, breast and prostate, are not present in zebrafish, limiting how certain tumour types can be studied. In addition, young zebrafish do not yet have a fully developed adaptive immune system, which restricts their use for studying complex interactions between tumours and the immune system. Their lower body temperature can also influence how transplanted human tumour cells behave. For questions requiring full immune responses, organ-specific cancer models or long-term disease progression, researchers therefore rely on complementary mammalian models, such as mice.

More about the role of zebrafish in biomedical research can be found here.  

Video from Cambridge University, UK, about how they use mice to study cancer, including a in-depth look at the facilities in which they are housed, exploring issues of animal welfare and the search for replacements.

Limitations of animal research in cancer

While animal research has driven major advances in cancer research, it has limitations that must be considered. Cancers in animals do not develop in the same way as they do in people. For example, tumours implanted into mice often grow faster and over a shorter time than human cancers, which can affect how well results predict long-term outcomes in patients. In that sense, non-human primates share closer genetic and physiological similarities with humans and can better reflect certain immune and drug responses. Even so, differences in genetics, immune systems and lifespan across species mean that some treatments that appear effective or safe in animals may perform differently in clinical trials. 
For this reason, findings from animal studies are carefully interpreted and routinely confirmed using multiple animal species, organoids, human cells and tissues, and clinical data before being applied to patient care.     

New approach methodologies in cancer research

New approach methodologies, or NAMs, such as organoids, stem cell cultures, computer modelling and artificial intelligence are increasingly used alongside animal studies. Mini tumours grown in the laboratory allow researchers to test treatments and study specific cancer mechanisms at a molecular and cellular level in controlled settings, while computational methods help model tumour growth and evolution. These systems can be built from a patient’s own tumour cells, allowing to test how an individual cancer responds to specific therapies. For example, personalised organ-on-a-chip have been used to recreate a patient’s tumour environment in the lab and predict whether chemotherapy is likely to be effective, supporting more tailored treatment decisions. 

Artificial intelligence is also accelerating cancer research by helping scientists design and optimise experiments. For example, a new AI tool developed by Stanford University Medical Center called CRISPR-GPT uses large volumes of published data to suggest experimental strategies and flag potential errors before laboratory work begins. In early tests, CRISPR-GPT successfully guided researchers in switching off genes that support tumour growth in lung cancer cells and activating genes linked to treatment resistance in skin cancer cells, with experiments working on the first attempt. Such tools can speed up discovery and make research more efficient. 

Cancer is a complex, whole-body disease that involves not only uncontrolled tumour growth but also interactions with blood vessels, the immune system and distant organs, particularly during metastasis - the spread of cancer to other parts of the body. NAMs currently capture only parts of cancer biology and cannot yet reproduce whole-body interactions, immune responses or long-term disease progression. As a result, they complement rather than replace animal research in cancer studies, which remains essential for understanding how cancer behaves within a living organism. 

Unfortunately, non-animal methods are not able at the moment to reproduce these complex environments and interactions… For this reason, we really need to use animals.

Tommaso Virgilio, Institute for Research in Biomedicine, Switzerland
Useful sources 
Involving animals in research, Cancer Research UK
Why do we support the use of animals in research?, Worldwide Cancer Research
Why is animal research still necessary to defeat cancer?, The Institute of Cancer Research
Cancer research history, Understanding Animal Research
Documentary "The Cancer Pioneers", Shelter Me PBS